This has been a great pizza for many years. But , all good things do come to an end. We order 2 to 3 pizzas a month and have Noticed since new owners a DECLINE in quality. We always order the Xtra large and the crust used to be decent up until now where the center is PAPER THIN. FOR $35 LAST PIZZA EVER
We are very sorry that you were not happy with your last order. just to clarify, the original owners are still here and have not left, and the recipes have not changed.
We do apologize that the quality of the pizza your received was not up to par. If you would like to give us your full name, we would like to replace that pizza for you at a time that is convenient.
Again, we do apologize and will speak to our staff.
I ordered your Saturday special with 2 pops and 2 Dipping sauce...63 dollars? I ordered extra cheese on top of the special. I will never again order from you and I will gladly spread the word amongst my friends
We are very sorry that you feel that your bill was too much. As per the conversation you had with our staff when placing your order, yes you had ordered our Saturday Special (extra large pizza which comes with three regular toppings), extra cheese counts as two toppings, 2 dips, drinks and an order of dough balls, taxes and a delivery charge of $7.00.
We are very sorry that you were not satisfied with the the total cost of your purchase, but we do take pride in our products and do our very best to provide each customer with the best service and product possible.
When ordering takeout we are doing our best to not gouge our customers, but provide them with the best possible product we can as food costs and wages have increased. We are not a franchise but a small home town mom and pop shop. We are doing our best. We did offer to give you a discount on your next order and you declined.
In addition we have not changed our menu prices in that last 4 to 5 years. Our new menu and prices will be released shortly.
On behalf of the management at Tops in Pizza, we are very sorry that you you were dissatisfied with your order.
Lived across Southern Ontario & travelled throughout North Eastern USA, their pizza is easily in “the best” realm! Amazing service & friendly as can be too. Been a regular since my first slice in 2020.
MaryJane just deliver a fantastic New Years Eve dinner of Veal Parm and potato plus and a dinner of Egg Parm and spaghetti plus garlic bread. It was 5 stars all the way
Best tasting pizza and garlic bread with cheese & bacon around. We use to get it for the prisoners. Now I know why they liked coming to court. Just to get pizza from Tops. First time I have ever tasted it after all these years. Pete and family you have a great pizza place. Will miss you. Enjoy your retirement. You have earned it. Thank You. Robin
Very disappointed.....Ordered a chicken ceasar salad and chicken Parm with lasagna. I asked for my salad to be mixed which they did not do. The homemade ceasar dressing used to be delicious. Now it's nothing more than mayonnaise with some oil in it. Not even a HINT of flavor in the sauce not to mention the chicken breast was TINY. Tops used to provide real bacon bits and croutons with the salad. Now it's fake bacon bits and a small package containing no joke 10 croutons. I used to enjoy this place but not since the owners have changed... won't be ordering again that's for sure
We are very sorry that you did not have a good experience. We take a lot of pride in our products as the majority of our products are made in house. We have not changed any of our recipes and everything is portioned and prepared as usual. We will definitely share this review with all staff in hopes that if there was an oversight, it will be corrected. We are very sorry for your negative experience and are offering to return your money or provide you with another meal if you are willing to return. Once again we are sorry for any inconveniences.
OMG. Started eating keto four months ago. Missed pizza. Friend told us Tops does Keto. Ordered ham crust pizza. Loved it!!! Our go to place for our new diet plan. Ordered on line. Wasn’t as long as it said it would be. ??. Can’t wait to try the keto sandwiches.
Best pizza place in town. Has been my favourite since I was a kid. And now it is my kids favorite. They wanted pizza tonight and I ordered myself the Keto pizza with the pepperoni base. I was worried I would still feel I was missing out while they ate the classic pizza as it's my favorite, but I didn't it all the keto pizza was delicious and satisfying! Their family run business definitely shows in their food made with love and good ingredients opposed to other chain pizza restaurants, there is no comparison. Thank you!
Yesterday we ordered a birthday lunch for our son's birthday. Pizza and Wings which were the best we every had. Also the dough balls filled with cheese, pepperoni and sauce were to die for. Thank you for making his day so special.
Had the turkey bacon sub. They ask if toasted. Why not. I'll be doing that again. mmmmm.... Real turkey. Real bacon None of that processed stuff here. I'll be back
Ordered the day before a large customer appreciation lunch. Could not have been more impressed. I called in to confirm an online order, the lady was so helpful and happy! The gentleman who delivered was so personable and took the time to let me know a bit about the restaurant, that little goes a long way! The food was on time and the quality was outstanding, wings were amazing! Garlic pizza and specialty pizza were impressive. All the little things were included. Huge appreciation to a business that shows they are not a run of the mill chain. While I don’t live anywhere close to Orilla, each time I am in town I will have to pop-in ! I never take the time to post reviews, but you guys really are fantastic
I hosted a baby shower for 25 people. Toni and Peter prepared chicken parmesan, pasta with meat sauce, caesar salad and garlic bread for us. All was excellent! The chicken parmesan portions were large and juicy and spectacular! The pasta and salad were wonderful! Everyone commented on how great the food was! Thank you Toni and Peter for preparing such a wonderful meal for our event! Cheers, Debbie
Walked in there for the first time today. What a great group of people. Very friendly and really helpful. Had their pepperoni based Keto pizza. Delish!! Going to try the other Keto pizzas also, the zucchini and the eggplant based ones. If they're anything like the pepperoni, I will be in heaven. P.S. They do welcome you like family. P.P.S. They are getting Keto buns and will be making Keto subs soon. I'm in my glory!! Thank you so much Tops in Pizza!
Great service the food was great and the young man who served us was wonderful I will definitely be coming back again TOPS is by far my favourite place to go for pizza
Thanks to Tops in Pizza for the complimentary pizza for the volunteers at OSMH! This has happened several times when they have delivered a large order for a group of staff. It is so thoughtful. Thank you for thinking of us!!
We’re truly blessed to have met you when we first introduced the pizza. You have educated us on many Keto options that were considering putting on our menu. We appreciate all the business that you have given us. At Tops, we want to make sure everyone has the same experience each time they walk into our restaurant.
Just had your dinner for 2 for the first time. We are stuffed to the max. It was absolutely delicious,We enjoyed every bite. Thanks so much, we will definitely order it again and recommend it to family and friends So glad we tried something different off your menu.
Best service, best food in town.Everytime I go there I feel like I’m about of the business, feels like home to me ?? it there. Thanks for the great food always
Most amazing owners and staff that work here with awesome pizza !! Thank you for everything that you do for our town , you guys are seriously the best !!!
I want to thank Tops In Pizza - I preordered some stuffed dough balls for a gathering is was going to and they where an absolute hit - trust me people TRY THEM - they where absolutely fantastic - thank you TOPS and I will be ordering again
This is the best pizza in town and the only place that offers fresh garlic as a topping for us garlic lovers. The pizza is always made on time and is nice and hot. There is no comparison between them and any of the local chains. I always order online from their website and I have never had to wait for my pizza ever. I just can't say enough good things about this family, they are amazing.
Our favourite spot in town! Delicious, home cooked meals with fresh and healthy ingredients. They cater to all dietary restrictions, which is a rare find. The staff are warm and friendly and we truly love coming here and enjoying their amazing food!
I have had the pleasure of eating their food since the early 70's - their home cooked meals are fabulous and over the years watching this family give so much to our community is truly amazing - thank you
Please do not review your own business. If you do, your review will show up highlighted in green and will be deleted.
You are responsible for the content of your review. You may be held liable if the content of your review is deemed to be defamatory.
This has been a great pizza for many years. 
Sign in to your account »
